The following are four palettes from the "I Dream of" Caribbean Collection. These are done on bare skin, no primer.


I Dream of Jamaica.


I Dream of Barbados.


I Dream of Nevis.


Aruba definitely has some of the best color payoff, but that's not surprising, because bronze shades tend to be softer and more pigmented in general. Beautiful colors, and possibly my favorite out of these four.
Jamaica is ok, but not amazing. I'm not sure if the last color is meant to be black or charcoal, but it's the chalkiest of the bunch, with the most fallout. Might be ok for a smoky eye, but I would probably stick with a more neutral eye design.
Barbados was a pleasant surprise, because purples are notoriously difficult. All the colors were workable, and if you were lemming the Dior Midnight Butterfly quint and couldn't justify the 56$ price tag, this might be something to tide you over until the lust passes. Really quite pretty.
Nevis has some lovely neutrals, except for the glitterbomb FAIL that is the second-to-last shade. Complete waste of a shade. However if you remove that one, this is avery good neutral, work-friendly palette. I prefer this one to the Jamaica, if you were choosing between the two.
These are nice but fairly simple colors. If you want something unique or dimensional, you won't find it in these palettes.
Overall I wouldn't compare these to high-end brands. They don't have the pigmentation and tenacity of the better MAC shades, the butteriness of Stila, the smooth silkiness of Dior. They tend to be more sheer overall (they wipe away easily), and the matte shades more powdery, but all in all, for 8$, you could do a LOT worse.
In terms of comparing these to the NYX singles, it really depends on the color you select, both in the palette and the singles. I've found there to be a lot more variability within each type than between them, if that makes any sense.
As I said, I did these swatches on bare skin to get a fair idea of application, but with a good primer or paintpot (or even foundation and powder) underneath, I think they are a good option if you're on a budget, or want to experiment with colors you don't usually wear. (Or if you're a beauty junkie like me and just like collecting.)
One more caveat - these are made in China, if that's a problem for you. (But then again, so are a lot of the holiday palettes that the Big Names put out.)
Available from www.nyxcosmetics.com, www.cherryculture.com and www.nonpareilboutique.com, as well as some drugstores and Ulta. Prices range from 8$ to 11$, depending on location, though you can always wait for discount codes at the websites.




